An engraving of Magellan's ship passing through the strait, surrounded by sea monsters, mermaids, a figure of Apollo, and fires burning on the shore.
Theodor de Bry, c. 1592

Magellan Takes a Carnival Cruise as 1521 Meets 2026

by Richard Downing
Fiction · October 2026
1.

He missed the open deck of masts and sails, but at least he had a window cabin, his health, thank God, and a fair chance of getting home. Still, Cozumel was not the Spice Islands and had been already discovered many times over by everyone from Mayan pillagers to spring break slackers hanging from balconies and parental credit cards. “Young heathens,” he thought. “Every one of them in need of conversion.” Or, failing that, execution. A slight loosening of fingers from railings should be enough.1

Magellan checked the brochure: the layover would be for four hours. Those who wanted to could stay aboard the Carnival cruise ship. Others could “Enjoy one of Cozumel’s premier snorkeling areas with thousands of colorful fish and amazing underwater views accessible right off the beach.”2 Magellan assumed that, to snorkel, he would have to remove his metal helmet or else the “amazing underwater views” might become, for him, permanent.

He reached up and tapped the metal skull that sat on his head and recalled the Battle of Mactan. But Cozumel was not the Philippines. And this was not 1521. The chances of being impaled on a poisonous spear were much less than being offered a cold beer.3 His hand reached up reflexively and lightly touched his shoulder, his fingers tracing the scar.

He had heard the natives here were Christian, that there was no need to convert the Rajah Lapu-Lapus of Mexico. Here, Magellan hoped, there would be no Rajah Lapu-Lapu, he of the markedly un-Christian soul, he of the poisoned arrows and heathen heart—if, in fact, the bastard had even had a heart.4

But Cozumel was not Mactan.5 The natives here came pre-converted and eager to please, happy to serve. And the spices were plentiful he’d been told. Magellan removed the helmet,6 placed it point up beside his Bible, and watched from his cabin window as the Carnival cruise ship approached the island.

2.

Back on board Magellan had the shits. “Montezuma’s Revenge” a crew member had called it. But what had Magellan ever done to Montezuma? “I could see it if I were Cortez.7 Perhaps we all look the same to these natives.8 No, it was probably just the tacos at the beachside bar.” Magellan had known better. But “When in Rome…” the waiter had said, pointing to the Spiced Taco Supreme on a laminated menu.

“Spices, enough with the spices.” Magellan tossed the brochure out of the bathroom, watched it open and flutter to an ignoble landing on a terminally damp tile floor, and proceeded to concentrate on the task at hand. No, not in hand, not that. The shits.

3.

Tonight he was scheduled to sit at the Captain’s table. “I am an admiral!”9 Magellan pronounced as he adjusted his metal hat in the bathroom mirror, making sure the metal point stood perfectly vertical from all directions. “The gringo should be eating at my table. If I had a table.” He looked at the man who shared his cabin. “Tonight I speak only Spanish. Perhaps some Portuguese. You will translate. Be sure the Captain knows that I am an admiral.”

“Will you be wearing your hat, Sir?”

“Yes, Enrique, of course.10 Protection. You can never be sure of lower ranking officers. You remember the mutiny. Drawing and quartering those captains on the beach of Puerto San Julian.”

“And impaling, Sir.”

“Yes, Enrique, ‘and impaling.’”11 Magellan smiled, hastily made the sign of the cross over his heart as if out of habit, then continued: “This Captain—perhaps he, too, has a heathen eye on the admiral’s rank. Is he a Christian, Enrique? Try to find out if he’s a Christian. If not we’ll go to work on him. And make sure the food is properly spiced, but less hot than that on Cozumel. And hand me that brochure off the floor. I’ve got to take a shit. Yes, another shit. Does this point look straight to you?”

4.

“Tell him I can get him a good price on cloves. Ask him if he needs cloves. Who wouldn’t want cloves? … What do you mean he thinks I’m funny? For God’s sake, I’m an admiral. Did you tell him that? … You tell this—” Magellan eyed the nametag on the starched white shirt worn by the man at the head of the table “—this ‘Captain Elcano’ that I am an admiral. … What do you mean he could tell from the hat that I’m something? Something? What thing? What thing does he think I am? Ask him that, Enrique. And pass the salt. This dish needs something.”12

5.

“Oh, dear Jesus, I’ve got the shits again. I swear to my loving God that that Captain is responsible for this, Enrique. Sitting so straight in that stiff white shirt, making sure everyone could see his nametag, see ‘Captain’ right above his name. I told you about his kind. Just like Gasper Quesada and Luis de Mendoza.13 And we know what happened to them, don’t we, Enrique? They, too, were captains, weren’t they? They, too, had ships as good as mine, didn’t they? The Conception and the Victoria. Perfectly fine sailing vessels. But they weren’t admirals, were they, Enrique? Oh, their machinations. Just like this Captain tonight. Oh how their kind want what is yours. Did you see his eyes light up when you told him I was an admiral? You did tell him I was an admiral?”

Enrique began to fan a brochure in Magellan’s direction.

“Oh for Christ’s sake, I’ll close the door if it’ll make you happy.” Magellan, shirtless, sat on the toilet, viewing himself in the mirror on the opposite wall. Again he reached to touch the round scar on his shoulder.14 “These shits will be the death of me yet.”

Magellan yelled through the closed door: “Enrique, I am not well, not well at all!” Then he cracked the door slightly and lowered an already failing voice: “Open the small chest next to my hat. Inside, under the cloves, is some paperwork. On my death your indentureship ends. You will be a free man. Read it, you’ll see. Just don’t get any ideas. Captain Elcano will be in charge. The way I feel right now, you may have to finish this trip without me.”

Notes
  1. Beach movies of the early 1960s such as Beach Blanket Bingo and How to Stuff a Wild Bikini starring Frankie Avalon and Annette Funicello helped spawn the spring break exodus of college students to Cozumel. Most researchers believe that Magellan never saw a beach movie and, if he had, would have disapproved of the “liberated” attitudes of the casts. Beaches, Magellan believed, were best suited for initiating attacks on native villages whose inhabitants refused conversion to Christianity and for executing mutinous captains and crew members. ↩
  2. Information taken from the Carnival Cruise Lines online brochure. ↩
  3. According to the Carnival Cruise Lines online brochure, “One drink after snorkeling is included in Carnival’s Zip Line/Snorkeling package.” There are no extant accounts of Magellan’s having or having not partaken. ↩
  4. Magellan’s unsuccessful attempts to convert Rajah Lapu-Lapu to Christianity led to Magellan’s fatal (for Magellan) attack on Lapu-Lapu’s village. ↩
  5. Magellan was killed on April 27, 1521, during the Battle of Mactan in the Philippines. ↩
  6. During the Battle of Mactan, Magellan’s metal helmet was twice knocked from his head. Magellan was swarmed and killed by natives loyal to Lapu-Lapu immediately after the second occurrence. ↩
  7. Initially, Montezuma, ruler of the Aztec nation, thought Hernando Cortez to be the God of Wisdom, therefore sending gifts instead of Aztec warriors. Later, in 1519, Cortez would kidnap Montezuma, threatening to kill the chieftain if he did not abide Cortez’s commands. Subsequently, Montezuma would be killed by his own people, Christianity would replace Aztec ritual, and the Aztec nation would vanish. ↩
  8. They did. ↩
  9. Though Portuguese, Magellan sailed under King Charles V of Spain, commanding five ships: the Trinidad, San Antonio, Concepción, Victoria, and Santiago. ↩
  10. Enrique was Magellan’s long-time indentured servant. ↩
  11. On April 2, 1520, along South America’s east coast, an unsuccessful mutiny involving two of Magellan’s ship captains broke out. ↩
  12. It is recorded here for the first time that Captain Elcano’s very distant relative, Juan Sebastián Elcano, upon Magellan’s death, captained the remaining ship, the Victoria, home to Spain. Of the 237 men who originally set sail with Magellan, 18 returned. ↩
  13. The mutinous captains. ↩
  14. According to conflicting accounts, Magellan was killed by a bamboo spear to the face, a bamboo spear to the arm, a cutlass wound to the left leg (TheMapHome.com), a poisoned arrow to the foot, a spear (composition unknown) to the heart (Who Goes There: European Explorers of the New World), a poisoned arrow through the right leg, stoning, and an assortment of iron spears (EyeWitness to History.com). Because such an assortment of wounds and scars would likely dampen the festive atmosphere Carnival Cruise Lines likes to imbue among its passengers, here Magellan is allowed but a single scar on his shoulder. ↩
The Author

Richard Downing has won the Nuclear Age Peace Foundation’s Peace Poetry Contest, New Delta Review’s Matt Clark Prize, and Solstice’s Editors’ Award. His work appears in over sixty journals, including Electric Literature, Malahat Review, Juked, and Consequence. He holds a PhD in English and votes with regularity.

Return to Contents